Curriculum Review: Shurley English

Concept: Based on grade level, Shurley English teaches grammar and writing skills by starting with simple sentences through teaching your child how to write 5 paragraph essays and narratives.

How It Works: Shurley English comes as a basic kit with Teacher’s Manual, Student Workbook, and Jingle CD. Each lesson is completely scripted, giving the home-school parent the exact words to stay to teach grammar and writing to their student. Each lesson is paired with jingles to help students remember the various parts of speech and basic grammar and writing rules. Each year starts out teaching the basic concepts, so you can start this program at any age/grade level. About the 4th week/chapter, students begin getting writing assignments, and older students will have two a week in addition to a weekly test. Shurley also incorporates weekly vocabulary words (8) to teach synonyms and antonyms, which help students improve writing skills. In addition to the kid books, you can add in vocabulary and literature selection books, as well as a practice book with all the sentences students have to classify.

How We Used It: For the younger grades we pretty much followed the script, doing jingles daily and reading the teaching text to give the kids a good base. As they got older, we found that the jingles became boring (because they already knew it) and we stopped using those after a couple of years. Additionally, because each year starts out with teaching the same basic ideas (just more quickly as students progress to higher grade levels) we began doing the first 1-3 chapters all the first week. We did all the writing assignments until the end chapters, which incorporate thank you cards and friendly letters. These we do at different times during the year, as appropriate (say after birthdays). After a few years, generally my kids just read the references in their workbooks that go with what they are learning and then do the activities. At this point (4th and 6th grades) Shurley requires very little teaching from me.

Concerns: The jingles get very boring and are not interesting to older kids. Two writing assignments each week can seem like a lot, especially to students who are not as interested in English (like my house full of math geeks).

Recommendation: We highly recommend Shurley English. While there are flaws with the system, in the end, the grammar and writing basis that this gives students is excellent, and that is the goal of English curriculum. In our opinion the grammar and writing preparation found in Shurley can’t be beaten. We also recommend purchasing the practice booklet as it saves time and hassle in the daily classification of sentences. The vocabulary madness books were too easy and just busy work, so we say skip those. If you aren’t using another reading curriculum, the literature selections are a great way to expose kids to prose and poetry at their grade level.

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s